Which State Constitutions Explicitly Prohibit Noncitizens from Voting

The 22 States With Explicit Constitutional Bans

As of the November 2026 elections, 22 state constitutions contain language explicitly prohibiting noncitizens from voting — not merely language saying “every citizen may vote,” but an express bar:

  • Alabama
  • Arizona (phrased negatively: “No person shall be entitled to vote … unless such person be a citizen of the United States”)
  • Arkansas (added Nov. 2026, ~69%)
  • Colorado (2020, ~63%)
  • Florida (2020, ~79%)
  • Idaho (2024, ~65%)
  • Iowa (2024, ~77%)
  • Kansas (added Nov. 2026)
  • Kentucky (2024, ~62%)
  • Louisiana (2022, ~73%)
  • Missouri (2024, ~68%)
  • North Carolina (2024, ~78%)
  • North Dakota (2018, ~66% — the first of the modern wave)
  • Ohio (2022, ~77%)
  • Oklahoma (2024, ~81%)
  • South Carolina (2024, ~86%)
  • South Dakota (added Nov. 2026, ~62%)
  • Texas (2025, ~72%)
  • Utah
  • West Virginia (added Nov. 2026, ~80%)
  • Wisconsin (2024, ~71%)
  • Wyoming

What the Other 28 States Actually Say

All 50 state constitutions mention U.S. citizenship in defining voter qualifications. The other 28 use affirmative language — “every citizen,” “all citizens” — which in practice still excludes noncitizens, but doesn’t contain an express prohibition. That distinction matters because affirmative language can be read as a floor rather than a ceiling, and it’s the crack through which municipal ordinances have slipped.

Why the Distinction Matters

  • Federal law is not the backstop people assume. The 1996 federal statute bars noncitizens only from federal elections — president, House, Senate. State and local elections are governed by state constitutions and statutes.
  • The real battlefield is municipal. The District of Columbia and municipalities in three states allow noncitizen voting in local elections. That’s precisely what the constitutional amendments are designed to preempt — closing the door before a city council opens it.
  • Ohio is the proof of concept. Yellow Springs amended its village charter in 2020 to let noncitizen residents vote locally. Ohio Issue 2 in 2022 overrode it at the constitutional level. That’s not a solution in search of a problem; it’s a response to one that already existed.
  • Arizona’s 2026 measure failed — but only because the state constitution already had the prohibition, and Prop 144 was bundled with voter ID, campaign finance, and election administration changes that gave voters reasons to balk.

The pattern is unmistakable: 15 constitutional amendments from 2018 through 2025, all passed, averaging roughly 73% support, plus four more in 2026. When a policy wins 60–86% of the vote across red and purple states alike, the claim that it’s addressing a phantom is itself the tell — the people pushing that line are the ones who want the local-option door left open.

No state constitution explicitly authorizes noncitizens to vote. Not one. Every state constitution mentions U.S. citizenship when defining voter qualifications, and 22 now contain express prohibitions.

The mechanism isn’t permission — it’s silence plus home rule. The other 28 states use affirmative language (“every citizen,” “all citizens”) that courts have generally read as a floor rather than a ceiling: the state must let all citizens vote, but that doesn’t necessarily mean the franchise is limited to citizens. Municipalities then fill the gap.

The States Where the Door Is Open

Legal scholarship (notably Joshua A. Douglas‘s work on local voting rights) identified 14 states with no clear constitutional or statutory impediment to municipalities setting their own voter qualifications. Six of those have since amended their constitutions. The eight remaining are:

  • California
  • Illinois
  • Maryland
  • Nevada
  • New Jersey
  • New Mexico
  • Rhode Island
  • Washington

Vermont belongs on this list in practice, though by a different route. Its constitution requires citizenship only for state elections, and the Vermont Supreme Court held as far back as Woodcock v. Bolster (1863) that the legislature has discretion over qualifications in purely local elections. That’s the doctrinal basis for Burlington, Montpelier, and Winooski.

Where Noncitizens Actually Vote Today

As of late 2026, 22 jurisdictions extend local voting rights to noncitizens:

  • Washington, D.C. — local elections, via the D.C. Noncitizen Vote Act (2022)
  • California
  • San Francisco — noncitizen parents/guardians vote for Board of Education. A Superior Court judge struck it down in 2022; the Court of Appeal reversed in 2023 and it’s operating.
  • Oakland — approved by voters in 2022 (67%), school board races; not yet implemented as of late 2026.
  • Maryland — roughly 16 municipalities, including Takoma Park, Hyattsville, Mount Rainier, Riverdale Park, Greenbelt, Frederick, Garrett Park, Glen Echo, Somerset, Cheverly, Brentwood, Colmar Manor, Edmonston, Barnesville, Martin’s Additions, and Chevy Chase Section 3. Several of these also let 16- and 17-year-olds vote.
  • Vermont — Burlington, Montpelier, Winooski. All three required the legislature to override Governor Phil Scott‘s veto.

Maryland is the outlier worth studying: its constitution explicitly grants municipalities authority to extend voting to people outside the state’s qualifications, without state approval. That’s not a loophole — it’s a delegation, written in.

Two Things the “It’s Rare” Framing Obscures

First, the trend line is one-directional for a reason. Fifteen constitutional amendments from 2018 through 2025, all passed, averaging ~73% support, plus four more in 2026. Legislators aren’t spending political capital on a non-issue. They’re preempting — and in Ohio’s case, retroactively overriding an actual charter amendment in Yellow Springs. The pattern is: locality opens the door, state constitution slams it.

Second, “rare” describes the count, not the trajectory. Twenty-two jurisdictions is small. But the expansion happened deliberately, city by city, in states whose constitutions were written before anyone thought to close the gap — and the reason it stopped is that voters started closing it.

What are the penalties if a non-citizen votes in federal, state, or local election

Federal law makes it a crime, state law makes it a crime (usually a felony), and the immigration consequences are often worse than the criminal ones. The penalties stack: a single illegal ballot can produce a federal misdemeanor conviction, a state felony, deportation, and a permanent bar to ever becoming a citizen.

Federal Penalties

The voting act itself — 18 U.S.C. § 611

  • Any non-citizen who votes in an election for President, VP, presidential elector, Senator, House member, or D.C. Delegate faces a fine, up to one year in prison, or both.
  • It’s a misdemeanor, but note the structure: if a ballot mixes federal and local races, the alien can only vote the local portion where a state constitution, statute, or local ordinance authorizes it — and only if that voting is conducted separately so there’s no opportunity to touch the federal races.
  • There’s a narrow safe harbor in § 611(c): both parents were/are U.S. citizens, the person permanently resided in the U.S. before age 16, and reasonably believed they were a citizen at the time of voting.

The paperwork crimes are where the years come from

  • 18 U.S.C. § 1015(f) — false claim of citizenship for the purpose of voting or registering: up to 5 years.
  • 18 U.S.C. § 911 — false personation of citizenship: up to 3 years.
  • 18 U.S.C. § 1001 — false statements to the government: up to 5 years.
  • 52 U.S.C. § 20511 — fraudulent voter registration or voting under the NVRA: up to 5 years.
  • 18 U.S.C. § 1621 — perjury on the registration affidavit: up to 5 years.

That’s the part most people miss. Signing the registration form is itself a sworn citizenship attestation — the exposure for registering is typically larger than for the ballot.

Immigration Consequences — Usually the Real Sentence

  • 8 U.S.C. § 1182(a)(10)(D)(i) — any alien who voted in violation of any federal, state, or local constitutional provision, statute, ordinance, or regulation is inadmissible.
  • 8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(6)(A) — the same conduct makes an admitted alien (green card holder included) deportable.
  • No conviction is required. Removal can rest on proof of the act alone.
  • It’s treated as a general intent offense — the government need not prove the person knew voting was illegal, only that they knew they weren’t a citizen and knew they were voting. The Seventh Circuit has said as much explicitly, rejecting the “nobody told me” defense.
  • The same narrow parent/residence/belief exception applies, and it’s construed tightly.

False claim to citizenship is a separate, permanent bar. Under INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(ii), a false claim to U.S. citizenship — including on a voter registration form — is a lifetime inadmissibility bar with no meaningful waiver. Not “come back in ten years.” Forever.

Naturalization is also off the table: unlawful voting is an express statutory factor against good moral character under INA § 101(f), and it creates a multi-year bar even where no prosecution follows.

State Penalties

State law varies, but the pattern is consistent: registration fraud and illegal voting are felonies or high misdemeanors, and the trend since 2020 has been toward explicit non-citizen voting statutes and constitutional amendments (Alabama, Colorado, Florida, Louisiana, North Dakota, Ohio, and others have amended their constitutions to say only citizens may vote).

State example Conduct Penalty
Louisiana Non-citizen registering or voting Felony — up to 2 years, up to $2,000, or both (with DMV notice requirement added in 2025)
Oklahoma False citizenship statement on registration Felony — up to 5 years, plus referral to the DA and U.S. Attorney
Most states Fraudulent registration / illegal voting Felony range typically 1–5 years plus fines, restitution of election costs, and permanent loss of registration

State penalties also routinely include loss of the right to vote upon any future naturalization, court-ordered restitution for recount costs, and in some states civil liability.

Local Elections

Here the answer flips depending on jurisdiction.

  • Where non-citizens are authorized to vote locally — roughly 16 cities and towns across California, Maryland, and Vermont, plus the District of Columbia — there is no penalty, because the conduct isn’t illegal. San Francisco allows non-citizen parents to vote in school board races; Takoma Park and others allow it in municipal elections. These jurisdictions keep separate voter lists so non-citizens never enter the statewide or federal rolls.
  • Where they are not authorized — which is everywhere else — local ordinances carry their own penalties, and prosecution typically runs through the state election code. The federal “mixed election” carve-out in § 611(a)(1)–(3) only protects the local vote if the state or locality actually authorized it and the federal races are physically separated on a different ballot or contest.
  • New York City’s 2021 ordinance allowing non-citizen municipal voting was struck down by the state Supreme Court in 2022 as violating the state constitution — so the “it’s legal in NYC” claim was never true in practice.

The Enforcement Reality

Here’s the part the official summaries glide past. The standard line — “audits and studies show non-citizen voting is extremely rare” — is an artifact of not looking, not a finding that nothing happens.

  • Most states have no systematic citizenship verification at the point of registration. The federal mail form runs on an honor-system attestation under penalty of perjury.
  • The proof-of-citizenship requirement on the federal registration form was tied up in litigation for years precisely because the machinery that would generate detection data was being fought.
  • Cross-checks that do exist — jury-duty excusals, DMV records, later naturalization files — routinely turn up registrants who should never have been on the rolls. Oklahoma’s own data showed removals after it started cross-referencing jury excusals; Georgia’s investigation logged over a thousand potential non-citizen registration attempts over 25 years, all blocked only because the system caught them late.
  • Prosecutions are rare — not because the conduct is rare, but because detection is rare, and because a case usually ends in removal proceedings rather than a courtroom, which is cheaper and produces no public docket.

The asymmetry is the tell: the same institutions that insist the problem is vanishingly small have spent a decade resisting the verification measures that would prove it.

©2026 . All rights reserved.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *