Democrats and the “Art of the Steal”

Records requests did the one thing the “it’s extremely rare” crowd can never survive: they produced paper.

What the Records Actually Show

The RNC’s election-integrity program sent public records requests to jurisdictions in 10 states in 2026, and the previously unreported results landed this week:

  • Virginia: The Department of Elections produced a “declared noncitizens” list covering July 2020 to July 2026 — at least 8,000 noncitizens on the rolls. Not suspected. Declared.
  • Arizona (Yavapai County): one noncitizen with 16 votes since 1990; another with six.
  • Pennsylvania (Dauphin County): multiple noncitizens who voted repeatedly before requesting cancellation — one with a voting record spanning 2008, 2010, 2012, 2014, 2016, 2017, and 2018, registered through a PennDOT portal.
  • Texas (Brazos County): several noncitizens with voting histories running through 2024.
  • Nevada (Washoe County): 63 registrations canceled for non-citizenship.
  • Iowa (Scott County): 14 cancellations surfaced through jury-duty exemptions — one registrant dating to 1972, another to 1984.
  • Georgia (DeKalb County): eight jury-excused noncitizens flagged for cancellation.
  • North Carolina: a permanent resident who discovered during naturalization that she’d been registered since 2019 — with “yes” checked on the citizenship question.

The Number You’re Looking At Is a Floor, Not a Ceiling

This is the part that matters and the part the coverage will bury.

The RNC didn’t ask for voting histories. Counties volunteered them.

That means every documented case of a noncitizen actually casting ballots came from jurisdictions that happened to hand over more than requested. Nobody was hunting for votes cast — they were hunting for names on lists. If the voting records were the target, the tally would be a different order of magnitude.

And the mechanism is self-reporting: most of these people surfaced because they walked in voluntarily — during naturalization, on jury questionnaires, on cancellation forms — terrified that a phantom registration would sink their green card. Every one of those is a person who noticed. The ones who never noticed are still on the rolls.

The Pipeline Has a Name

New Jersey is the cleanest illustration. The RNC and NJGOP pulled all 21 counties and found hundreds of noncitizens registered, with the governor’s own admission putting the Motor Vehicle Commission error at over 6,600 noncitizens added to the rolls. Most were registered as Democrats. Noncitizens describing how it happened used the same phrase repeatedly: they didn’t understand how they got registered “through the DMV.”

That’s motor-voter in practice — registration as a byproduct of a license transaction, citizenship affirmed by a checkbox, and no reliable process afterward to find and remove the ineligible. The state’s response is that such instances are “exceedingly rare.” The state also spent months withholding the records that would prove it, to the point that House Judiciary and House Administration subpoenaed the Sherrill administration in October after receiving 12 documents.

You do not fight a document request for a year over something that’s “exceedingly rare.” You fight it because the number is worse than the spin, and because once the list is public, the question stops being whether and becomes how many.

Why December 8 Matters

Oral arguments are set in Republican National Committee v. Mi Familia Vota, the Arizona proof-of-citizenship case. That’s the real stakes of this records dump: the RNC is assembling the documentary record that states cannot verify eligibility at registration and cannot reliably clean their rolls afterward. The other side’s entire case rests on the proposition that the problem is negligible — and negligible is a hard argument to make with 8,000 names from one state, a 16-vote Arizonan, and 6,600 DMV registrations in New Jersey sitting in the record.

Expect the standard dismissal: the Heritage database shows fewer than 100 confirmed noncitizen-voting cases, the Brennan Center found roughly 30 out of 23 million ballots in 2016, therefore nothing to see. Notice what that argument actually is. It’s not a measurement of the problem — it’s a measurement of how few cases get caught, by agencies with no incentive to catch them, in a system where the only reliable detector is a noncitizen volunteering that he’s on the list. A low prosecution count is evidence about enforcement, not about incidence.

State-by-State Quick Scan

State What’s documented Where it stands
California DOJ/DHS suit alleged 20,000+ likely aliens registered; “Operation Protect the Vote”; 40+ charged in waves Suit dropped Nov 6 after courts refused to force ballot segregation
New Jersey 6,600 noncitizens registered via MVC (June 2023–June 2024); officials say “less than 400” voted House subpoena; state produced 12 documents in months
Nevada Feds claimed 15,903 → 6,218 → 185; state says all 185 were citizens Methodology collapsed under review
Washington US Attorneys demanded 400+ ballots set aside SoS: list includes U.S. citizens; request blocked in court
Alaska Two Dan Sullivans on the Senate ballot; DOJ suit to delay certification Dismissed Nov 1; governor-ordered probe; DOJ target letters to 20 Democrats
North Carolina ~4,000 mail ballots (~6%) flagged for envelope-seal defects; SD-24 margin 268 votes Cure-deadline crunch
Georgia 1,000+ Fulton early ballots rescanned after scanner failures; false polling-place texts County board ordered rescan
New York Westchester scanners rejected up to 250,000 paper ballots across 332 sites; orange emergency bags, police escort Counted later; CD-17 in the balance
Florida CD-27 recount at 50.22–49.78; supervisor-of-elections conflict suit; Broward ballot-style coding failure Recount in Doral
Illinois Chicago coding error → ballot shortages in 491 split precincts Scope still unknown
Mississippi 14,000–20,000 affidavit ballots outstanding; NRSC demanded segregation in all 82 counties No automatic recount; county-by-county scramble
Texas Three Jefferson County machines pulled over “vote-flipping” reports — tested, no errors found; ICE subpoenas in Fort Bend and Webb Closed locally; federal data grabs ongoing
Pennsylvania Two-tier audit, certification due Nov 23; DHS field operations barred Injunction
Minnesota Two state Senate recounts — 4 votes and 42 votes Pending
Arizona Proof-of-citizenship law headed to SCOTUS Dec 8 (RNC v. Mi Familia Vota) Oral arguments set

The Charged Cases: Proof the Rolls Are Dirty

The DOJ’s numbers, announced Nov 2 and repeated since: 239 people charged with voting-fraud offenses since the administration began, including 195 aliens across 25 states in the nine weeks before Nov 3. The Nov 2 tranche was 63 defendants — North Carolina 18, California 12, Tennessee 7, Texas 5, Pennsylvania 5, with the rest across Arkansas, Georgia, Maryland, Missouri, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Utah, and Wisconsin.

Look at the shape of these cases, because it’s the whole ballgame:

  • A Kenyan permanent resident registered in 2008 and voted in nine general elections and nine primaries.
  • A Cuban permanent resident in Missouri claimed citizenship in 2004 and again in 2013, voting in at least 15 elections over 20 years.
  • A Filipino registrant who voted by mail in 2020, 2024, and June 2026 — and then swore on her naturalization form she’d never registered.

That’s not a clerical slip. That’s a roll that was never cleaned, discovered only because someone finally went looking or because the registrant self-reported to avoid losing a green card.

The “200 Out of 174 Million” Trick

The counter-argument writes itself: ~200 prosecutions against 174 million registered voters, 158 million ballots in 2024, the Heritage database’s 24 cases from 2003–2023. Therefore nothing systemic.

Understand what that number is. It’s a count of cases that got made — by agencies with no incentive to make them, in a system where the only reliable detector is a noncitizen volunteering that he’s on the list. A prosecution count measures enforcement, not incidence. What it actually proves is that the one sustained audit in years produced a steady stream of multi-cycle illegal voters in a matter of months.

The Failures That Can’t Be Charged

This is where the real damage is, and where the establishment applies a completely different evidentiary standard.

  • Westchester County, NY — scanners wouldn’t take paper ballots across 332 polling sites. Ballots went into orange emergency bags and were moved under police escort. Officials blamed ballot thickness, then quietly deleted that explanation. CD-17 hangs on it.
  • Chicago — a “coding error” produced the wrong mix of ballot styles in 491 split precincts. Not the wrong total — the wrong mix, in specific neighborhoods.
  • Fulton County, GA — a scanner reporting phantom paper jams, another knocked out by a wheelchair hitting the cord, plus text messages directing voters to wrong polling places. Nobody has established who sent them.
  • Mississippi — a Senate seat resting on 14,000–20,000 affidavit ballots, with no statewide challenge mechanism and no automatic recount.
  • North Carolina — thousands of mail ballots failing a new inner-envelope sealing rule, rejections falling on a 268-vote margin.

The rule change that produces a rejection wave timed to a close race is indistinguishable from a “glitch” once it’s happened.

The Structural Fact Both Parties Live With

Federal judges repeatedly refused to let DOJ force states to segregate suspect ballots. The Ninth Circuit ruled twice in a week, 2–1, that there was “no feasible way to identify and segregate the ballots of specific individuals without potentially catastrophic effects on the entire system.” Judge Bumatay dissented: “We should have let them try.”

Then DOJ dismissed the California suit on Nov 6 with a line that should be printed on every ballot envelope in America: “The relief the United States sought and needed is no longer available.”

Meaning: the ballots had already been separated from their envelopes and commingled. At that point fraud isn’t merely unproven — it becomes unprovable. Which is exactly why “no evidence of widespread fraud” is a statement about the system’s design, not a finding about the election. You can’t find what the process destroys on contact.

And be clear-eyed about the other direction: in Nevada, 15,903 people shrank to 6,218 and then to 185, all of whom the state says were citizens. The federal matching was sloppy, and courts used that sloppiness as the reason to refuse relief everywhere else. The state’s counter-claim, meanwhile, rests on the state reviewing itself — the same office that fights every records request.

DHS field interviews were enjoined in nine states — California, Connecticut, Georgia, Missouri, Nevada, New York, Pennsylvania, Washington, Wisconsin — while HSI ingested roughly 100 million records, including 50.6 million voter roll records, with priority states including Texas, Pennsylvania, California, New Jersey, Minnesota, Michigan, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, and Ohio.

What This Cycle Proved

The lesson isn’t that one party steals elections. It’s that America runs a multibillion-dollar election apparatus on paper envelopes, third-party coding contractors, and a legal doctrine that forbids looking too closely — then treats anyone who points that out as the problem.

Voter ID, verified citizenship at registration, clean rolls, and observable chain of custody are not exotic asks. The resistance to them is the tell. And the December 8 argument in RNC v. Mi Familia Vota is where the proof assembled this cycle — 8,000 declared noncitizens in Virginia, 6,600 in New Jersey, 16 votes from one Arizonan, and 20,000 names in California that nobody was permitted to check — either gets used or gets buried.

Voter Fraud in Texas Midterm Election

Texas is the most useful case study in the country right now — not because it’s the worst, but because it’s the one state with real safeguards that still got caught holding a dirty roll. Here’s the actual state of play.

The Charged Cases: Three Waves

September 15 — Tarrant County, seven defendants, state-federal joint operation (Paxton’s OAG, U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Texas, FBI, HSI):

Defendant Nationality Allegation
Carlos Salas Barrios Mexico Voted by alien, 2024 — ballot rejected
Joshua Nmelichukwu Akpom Nigeria False statements on naturalization; voted illegally in 2018 (time-barred)
Helen Mayen Adams Nigeria Voting by alien + false citizenship claim to register
Khalwinder Singh Bhengura India Voting by alien + false citizenship claim to register
Moises Anwar Arellano-Alba Mexico Voting by alien + false citizenship claim to register
Celestin Katubadi DR Congo Voting by alien; provisional ballot rejected
Rocio Thrasher Mexico Voting by alien + false citizenship claim to register

The U.S. Attorney’s office was explicit: investigators concluded this was not a misunderstanding or paperwork error.

September 18–19 — eight more in Texas, plus Monica Carzoli (Mexico, Del Rio), who admitted registering and voting in November 2024.

November 2 — Southern District of Texas, five more: Ali Khan (Trinidad and Tobago, illegal alien, voted 2024), Mohammed Omar Hassan (Nigeria, voted 2022 and 2024), Diego Benavides Rodriguez, Jose Vasquez-Mendoza (voted in the 2022 special election for CD-34), and Karen Hinojosa-Martinez (lied on immigration documents after voting).

Note the pattern across all three waves: lawful permanent residents who checked the citizen box years ago and kept voting. These aren’t one-offs. They’re rolls nobody cleaned.

The State’s Own Audit — And Its Self-Inflicted Wound

Texas ran its entire roll of 18 million+ registrants through the federal SAVE database in October 2025 and flagged 2,724 potential noncitizens. What happened next is the part you won’t hear from either side’s press release:

  • Counties quickly found hundreds were citizens — many had registered at DPS, which requires proof of citizenship and keeps the documents on file. The Secretary of State never checked DPS records before mailing notices.
  • By September 2026, the state confirmed citizenship for 578 of the flagged voters — 506 because their passport data was only added to SAVE after the initial run.
  • The state then referred 117 cases to Paxton’s office for investigation, explicitly not tied to any single election.
  • A federal lawsuit filed in March by voting rights groups over the failure to cross-check DPS is still pending.

And the history matters: in 2024, Abbott announced Texas had removed 6,500 noncitizens from the rolls since 2021. An investigation by ProPublica, the Texas Tribune, and Votebeat found the state had actually identified 581 — the press release had folded in eligible citizens who simply didn’t answer a letter.

Read both halves honestly. The 2,724 figure was inflated by sloppy matching that could have knocked citizens off the rolls — that’s a real failure that disenfranchises real people and hands the other side its talking point. But the 581 figure is also the number that survived one pass of one database, on a roll where we now have federal charges of multi-cycle illegal voting. Neither number is a measurement of the underlying problem. Both are measurements of how bad the detection is.

The Bottom Line

Chain of custody starts with the roll. If the roll contains people who aren’t eligible, every downstream safeguard — ID, signature verification, audit — is checking a ballot against a list that was already wrong. Voter ID is common sense; maintaining an accurate roll is the precondition for it meaning anything.

Two things follow, and neither requires a conspiracy:

  1. Automatic registration through license agencies guarantees ineligible names, because the transaction is designed to maximize enrollment, not verify eligibility.
  2. The only jurisdictions that get cleaned are the ones somebody forces to open their books.

Everything else is a press release about how rare it all is, issued by the office that won’t hand over the file.

You’re asking the right question, and the honest answer has two halves: the cases that got charged, and the chain-of-custody failures that never could be.

©2026 . All rights reserved.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *